ImmunoScience, Inc.


Other References on Saliva Based HIV Tests


[Previous Page] [Next Page] [Up] [Home Page] [Mail] [Contents]

The least expensive way to determine infection by the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) is to test for the presence of HIV antibodies. Diagnostic testing is done in two stages, a screening test and a confirmatory test. The screening test is done on the initial submitted blood specimen, usually with an enzyme-linked immunoadsorbent assay (ELISA). If non-reactive for HIV antibodies, the screening test is termed negative and no further testing is done. If reactive or inconclusive for HIV-antibodies, the screening test is repeated but this time with a confirmatory test such as the Western blot, immunoflourescent assay (IFA), or two different ELISA. If the confirmatory test is positive, the person likely has been infected with the HIV virus. Because of the serious nature of this diagnosis and the possibilities of test or laboratory error, persons who are diagnosed HIV positive are typically asked to return at a later time for another independent diagnostic test.

In the United States, all persons who obtain the HIV test are expected to be counseled, both before the blood specimen is collected and after the results are known. The cost of such testing is high, usually ranging from about $50-75 for a negative test sequence to $150-175 for a positive test sequence. At federally-funded HIV testing centers in the United States, more than 95 percent of persons receiving blood tests are found to be negative. Thus the majority of funds spent by the US government for HIV testing goes to counseling and testing of uninfected persons.

An alternative to blood testing is to use saliva which also contains HIV antibodies, but at lower concentrations. Many investigators have studied and evaluated saliva tests and found them to be almost as valid as blood tests. Validity is measured by sensitivity, the percentage that measures positive with the test among those who truly have HIV antibodies, and specificity, the percentage that measures negative with the test among those who truly do not have HIV antibodies.

Saliva tests have been recommended and used for population surveys, surveillance programs, and personal screening. The test would be especially useful for rapid screening since the saliva specimen could be tested in the doctor's office, a clinic or even in the privacy of a home, and, if the screening test is positive, the person would be referred to a health care provider for counseling and diagnostic testing with blood. With such a system, the percentage of persons at testing centers who are HIV negative would be greatly decreased, allowing more time and effort to be spent on those truly infected with the deadly virus. Such personal screening programs, however, are not yet legal in the United States because of the higher gravity associated with such systems by the FDA. The situation in the developing world is quite different in that there is a shortage of resources, the populations are less educated and not as accessible for follow-up as in the United States. It is extremely important therefore, to not apply the same criteria for testing adequacy in the developing world from an epidemiological and public health perspective as are applied in the United States.

A summary of all publications on saliva tests that have appeared to date is shown below:


Published Study of HIV antibody assays using Saliva, 1987-1995
CollectionHIV
AuthorsMethodsAntibody AssayHIV +HIV -Sensitifity (%)Specificity (%)
Parry et. al., 1987Free DripGAC ELISA4310100.0100.0
Free DripGACRIA4110100.0100.0
Johnson et. al, 1988Free DripWellcome ELISA196460100.099.8
Free DripWellcome ELISA16540590.999.8
Free DripAbbot ELISA18444382.1100.0
Free DripFujirebio PA17942197.884.1
Holmstrom et al, 1990Stimulated DripVironostika ELISA361497.2100.0
O'Shea et al, 1990Mouth WashAbbot ELISA22--90.0--
Archibald et al, 1991Free DripASQ ELISA21--95.2---
Behets et al, 1991Free DripVironostika ELISA14531397.9100.0
Major et al, 1991Not StatedCambridge ELISA11942998.3100.0
Croffs et al, 1991SalivetteGACELISA505098.0100.0
SalivetteAbbot ELISA505088.0100.0
Coates et al, 1991Free DripCambridge EIA11323100.0100.0
Van den Akker et al, Free DripVironostika ELISA79115100.0100.0
1992
Klokke et al, 1991Not StatedGACELISA4248100.0100.0
Gershy-Damet et al, Free DripGACELISA3243100.097.7
1992
Soto-Ramirez et al, 1992OrasureOrganon Teknika 356152499.4100.0
ELISA
Frerichs et al, 1992Omni-SalCambridge EIA7440190.599.5
(Myanmar)
Omni-SalCambridge EIA7440094.699.5
(USA)
Omni-SalCambridge EIA--1025--100.0
(Myanmar)
Omni-SalCambridge EIA--1025--100.0
(USA)
Thongcharoen et al, Free-DripGACELISA5455100.0100.0
1992
Coveil et al, 1993SalivetteGACELISA494100.0100.0
Hunt et al, 1993Cotton swabGACELISA8214100.0100.0
Cotton swabGACRIA1827394.4100.0
Connell et al, 1993SalivetteGACELISA50127100.0100.0
Chamnarput et al, 1993Free DripDB ELISA HIV-110010094.489.0
Free DripGenelavia 10010096.6100.0
HIV-1/HIV-2
Free DripAbbott Testpack100100100.0100.0
HIV-1/HIV-2
Free DripRecombigen100100100.0100.0
HIV-1/HIV-2 RTD
Holm-Hansen et al,1993OrasureAbbot EIA4124492.7100.0
OrasureAbbot Testpack44243100.0100.0
OrasureMurex SUDS-13623097.2100.0
Urgula et al, 1993Not StatedSandwich Indirect505096.0100.0
Immummoassay
Frerichs et al, 1994Omni-SalGACELISA751405100.099.9
Omni-SalCambridge EIA75140593.399.9
Omni-SalAbbott HIVAB EIA75140598.799.1
Chassany et al, 1994Omni-SalGACELISA115451100.0100.0
Frerichs et al, 1994Omni-SalGACELISA3001654100.0100.0
Lu et al, 1994Omni-SalAbbott EIA5752100.0100.0
Omni-SalAbbot Testpack5752100.0100.0
King et al, 1995Omni-SalCambridge EIA36888897.3100.0
Emmoris et al, 1995OrasureAbbott HIVAB EIA195198100.0100.0
Vall Mayans et al,1995Omni-SalGACELISA133153100.098.7

REFERENCES

  1. Parry JV, Perry KR, Mortimer PP. Sensitive assays for viral antibodies in saliva: an alternative to tests on serum. Lancet1987; 335: 7275.
  2. Johnson AM, Parry JV, Best SJ, Smith AMA, Mortimer PP. HIVsurveillance by testing saliva. Aids 1988; 2(5):369-371.
  3. Holmstrom P, Syrjanen S, Laine P, Valle SL, Suni J. HIV antibodies in whole saliva detected by ELISA and western blot assays. J Med Virology 1990; 30(4): 245-248.
  4. O'Shea S, Cordery M, Barrett WY, Richman DD, Bradbeer C, Banatvala JE. HIV excretion patterns and specific antibody responses in body fluids. J Medical Virology 1993; 31(4): 291-296.
  5. Archibald DW, Hebert CA. Salivary detection of HIV1 antibodies using recombinant HIV1 peptides. Viral Immunology 1991; 4(1): 1722.
  6. Behets F, Edidi B, Quinn TC, et al. Detection of salivary HIV1specific IgG antibodies in highrisk populations in Zaire. Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes 1991; 4(2):183-187.
  7. Major CJ, Read SE, Coates RA, et al. Comparison of saliva and blood for human immunodeficiency virus prevalence testing.Journal of Infectious Diseases 1991; 163(4): 699-702.
  8. Crofts N, Nicholson S, Coghlan P, Gust ID. Testing of saliva for antibodies to HIV1. Aids 1991; 5(5): 561563.
  9. Coates R, Millson M, Myers T, et al. The benefits of HIV antibody testing of saliva in field research. Canadian Journal of Public Health 1991; 82(6): 397-398.
  10. van den Akker R, van den Hoek JA, van den Akker WM, et al. Detection of HIV antibodies in saliva as a tool for epidemiological studies. Aids 1992; 6(9): 953-957.
  11. Klokke AH, Ocheng D, Kalluvya SE, et al. Field evaluation of immunoglobulin G antibody capture tests for HIV1 and HIV2 antibodies in African serum, saliva and urine [letter]. Aids 1991;5(11): 1391-1392.
  12. GershyDamet GM, Koffi K, Abouya L, et al. Salivary and urinary diagnosis of human immunodeficiency viruses 1 and 2 infection in Cote d'Ivoire, using two assays. Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 1992; 86(6):670-671.
  13. SotoRamirez LE, HernandezGomez L, SifuentesOsornio J, et al. Detection of specific antibodies in gingival crevicular transudate by enzymelinked immunosorbent assay for diagnosis of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 infection. Journal of Clinical Microbiology 1992; 30(11): 2780-2783.
  14. Frerichs RR, Htoon MT, Eskes N, Lwin S. Comparison of saliva and serum for HIV surveillance in developing countries. Lancet 1992; 340: 1496-1499.
  15. Thongcharoen P, Wasi C, Louisirirotchanakul S, Parry J, Connell J, Mortimer P. Immunoglobulin G antibody capture enzymelinked immunosorbent assay: a versatile assay for detection of antihuman immunodeficiency virus type 1and 2 antibodies in body fluids. Journal of Clinical Microbiology 1992; 30(12): 3288-3289.
  16. Covell R, Follett E, Coote I, et al. HIV testing among injecting drug users in Glasgow. Journal of Infection 1993; 26(1):2731.
  17. Hunt AJ, Connell J, Christofinis G, et al. The testing of saliva samples for HIV1 antibodies: reliability in anonclinic setting. Genitourinary Medicine 1993; 69(1): 2930.
  18. Connell JA, Parry JV, Mortimer PP, Duncan J. Novel assay for the detection of Immunoglobulin G antihuman immunodeficiency virus in untreated saliva and urine. Journal of Medical Virology 1993; 41: 159-164.
  19. Chamnanput J, Phanuphak P. Comparison of eight commercial test kits for detecting antiHIV antibodies in saliva specimens [letter]. Aids 1993; 7(7): 1026
  20. HolmHansen C, Constantine NT, Haukenes G. Detection of antibodies to HIV in homologous sets of plasma, urine and oral mucosal transudate samples using rapid assays in Tanzania. Clinical and Diagnostic Virology 1993; 1(3): 207-214.
  21. Urquia M, RodriguezArchilla A, GonzalezMoles MA, Ceballos A. Detection of antiHIV antibodies in saliva. Journal of Oral Pathology and Medicine 1993; 22(4): 153-156.
  22. Frerichs RR, Eskes N, Htoon MT. Validity of three saliva assays for HIVantibodies. Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes 1994; 7(5): 522-524.
  23. Chassany O, Bergmann JF, Mazeron MC, et al. Testing of antiHIV antibodies in saliva. Aids 1994; 8(5): 713
  24. Frerichs RR, Silarug N, Eskes N, et al. Salivabased HIV antibody testing in Thailand. Aids 1994; 8: 885-894.
  25. Lu XS, Delfraissy JF, GrangeotKeros L, Rannou MT, Pillot J. Rapid and constant detection of HIV antibody response in saliva of HIVinfected patients; selective distribution of antiHIV activity in the IgG isotype. Research in Virology 1994; 145: 369-377.
  26. King A, Marion SA, Cook D, et al. Accuracy of a saliva test for HIV antibody. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr Hum Retrovirol 1995; 9: 172-175.
  27. Emmons WW, Paparello SF, Decker CF, Sheffield JM, LoweBey FH. A modified ELISA and western blot accurately determine antihuman immunodeficiency virus type 1 antibodies in oral fluids obtained with a special collecting device. Journal of Infectious Diseases1995; 171: 1406-1410.
  28. Vall Mayans M, Casabona J, Rabella N, De Miniac D. Comparison of saliva and serum for HIV testing among populations with high risk behaviors. European J Clinical Microbiology and Infectious Diseases 1995 (In Press)


[Up] SALIVAX™
[Home] Home Page
[Mail] Send EMail to ImmunoScience, Inc.
[Contents] ImmunoScience, Inc. Contents

Please note that ImmunoScience's products are the subject of many US and International patent applications. This document does not convey any rights to develop, manufacture, use or sell anything described herein.